Obie (Erica Marks) is second-in-command in the Vigils, an established student secret society at Trinity High School. Brother Leon (Adam McCort) enlists the Vigils' help, wishing to use their influence to convince students to sell overpriced fundraiser chocolates. When new student, Jerry Renault (Garrett Hnatiuk), refuses to participate, Obie attempts to persuade him to sell the chocolates. Obie and Jerry begin a secret romance, though Jerry continues to refuse to sell. As Obie witnesses the Vigils escalate their bullying and harassment tactics against Jerry, she is forced to examine her involvement with the elite group that once protected her, but that now seems ready to destroy everyone she cares about.